The couple lives near Bancroft Bay Park, and they decided to take a look around after the first clue was published. The medallion was located under the roof of the information kiosk in the lower parking lot.

Nate and Holly also found the medallion in 2011. They received $300 in Chamber Bucks for their efforts. The medallion hunt is sponsored by the Albert Lea-Freeborn County Chamber of Commerce as part of the Big Freeze winter festival.