Ex-cop pleads guilty to killing woman, ditching her body

Published 9:15 am Tuesday, January 26, 2016

MILWAUKEE — A former suburban Milwaukee police officer accused of killing two women and ditching their bodies in suitcases along a rural Wisconsin highway pleaded guilty Monday in one of their deaths.

Steven Zelich could spend the rest of his life behind bars after admitting to reckless homicide in the 2012 strangulation death of Jenny Gamez. Authorities said the 19-year-old Oregon woman died during a sexual encounter in Kenosha, and that Zelich hid her body before dumping it in 2014.

Details of the case are similar to accusations Zelich faces in the 2013 death of Laura Simonson in Minnesota. Authorities said Zelich met both women online, choked them at hotels and stashed their bodies in suitcases.

Email newsletter signup

in the trunk of his car before dumping them along the side of the highway.

Zelich, 54, faces two counts of hiding a corpse in Walworth County, where the suitcases were found by highway workers mowing the grass in June 2014. After those charges are resolved, Minnesota prosecutors could move to extradite him so he can face trial in Simonson’s death.

The plea deal in Gamez’s case was announced the same day the trial was expected to begin in Kenosha, about 30 miles south of Milwaukee.

Kenosha County Deputy District Attorney Michael Graveley said he would seek the maximum 75-year term, which includes at least 55 years in prison and 20 years extended supervision.

“It’s just too dangerous a set of behaviors to allow him to be out of custody,” Graveley said after the hearing.

Zelich’s attorney, Jonathan Smith, wouldn’t reveal why his client decided to plead guilty

“He decided for reasons that, thus far, are personal to him, that he didn’t want to go to trial,” he said.

Sentencing is scheduled for March 30.

Prosecutors have said Zelich invited the Gamez to Wisconsin, where they spent several days at a hotel in Kenosha. Zelich told investigators that after he choked Gamez, he put her body in her suitcase and took it to his apartment. He said he then put the body is his refrigerator in West Allis, about 5 miles west of Milwaukee.